Story Time: Guillain Barre Syndrome
Story Time:
Guillain Barré Syndrome is an autoimmune disorder that is present in the body and awakened into activity by a challenge to the immune system. The influenza virus is known to trigger the activation of GBS. Since influenza vaccines also mildly challenge the immune system, about 1 in 1 million people will have an activation of GBS after being vaccinated (however it’s reasonable to believe that if the inactive virus in the vaccine could wake it up, then infection with the live virus would have certainly resulted in activation.) The risk of the vaccine triggering GBS scares a lot of people. Most people do not understand how the influenza vaccine can both protect against GBS while also rarely triggering the thing it’s supposed to prevent.
It may help if we think of Guillain Barré as a sleeping giant then think of influenza infection as a big loud ogre and the influenza vaccine as a tiptoeing fairy. If the giant is awoken by a tiptoeing fairy, then it almost certainly would have been awoken by a loud ogre. We do not know which individuals are harboring the sleeping giant named Guillain Barré. Once inside, if the tiptoeing fairy was successful in not waking the giant (and she almost always is) she casts a spell making the loud ogre (influenza) invisible, silent, and incapable of waking the sleeping giant.
In this way, receiving the influenza vaccine actually reduces the risks of GB activation by the influenza virus in patients who unknowingly harbor this sleeping giant.
First off, I had a pretty bad case of GBS. Triggered by food poisoning
that said I came across your blog looking for ammunition to throw back at the anti-vaxxers. Especially those telling me they don’t want to get a covid vaccine because it could trigger the illness I had. I really like this analogy”If the giant is awoken by a tiptoeing fairy, then it almost certainly would have been awoken by a loud ogre. ”
but is there any science that I can show people to back that up?
Here is a review of the incidence of GBS in South Korea comparing influenza vaccination and influenza infection for the risk ratio of GBS in the interval time immediately following vaccination and the background incidence rate of GBS.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7563234/
They did a similar study looking at the French population and found a similar interval risk ratio.
https://n.neurology.org/content/94/20/e2168.long
The findings in both of these studies show that there is a significantly lower risk for GBS post influenza vaccination, and that this risk is lower than the actual disease itself.